Democrat and Republican views on Affirmative Action

Why and to what extent do democrats support Affirmative Action?

⇒ Support big government - the democrats believe the federal government should help vulnerable people

⇒ It has made the US a fairer place - black middle class has developed and re-districting has allowed for more diversity of the house of representatives

⇒ Continued need for affirmative action - evidence of inequality, racial profiling and Trump refusing to condemn the KKK

⇒ A majority of blacks support democrats and affirmative action benefits them - want to attract their votes (88% voted for Clinton)

⇒ Believe the Constitution is flawed - it allowed slavery so we need to right these wrongs. Affirmative action ensures equality of opportunity

However

⇒ Blue dog democrats oppose affirmative action

⇒ Public sector more likely to opposed affirmative action as some feel it disadvantages them

⇒ Affirmative action policies that were divised to ensure blacks would have access to jobs they would have been denied "directly affected white Catholics" - in other words, affirmative action increased competition for those people and thus gave Republicans these votes

Why and to what extent to republicans support affirmative action?

⇒ Conservatives prefer limited government and believe the government shouldn't interfere with the state's rights. Affirmative action interferes with states' rights, so they're opposed

⇒ Unconstitutional as " all men are created equal" - affirmative action doesn’t provide equal opportunity and prevents self-reliance so can be seen as reverse discrimination

⇒ It is unfair - why should white Americans pay for what some of their ancestors did? Some blacks owned slaves. Other minority groups have fared well without affirmative action too (Chinese, Irish)

⇒ Unnecessary - many blacks have prospered in recent years (like Obama) and segregation is a choice. Racism is no longer as prevalent in the South (hence why the supreme court struck down parts of the Voting Rights Act 1965)

⇒ Affirmative action lowers standards and creates a stigma

However

⇒ Condoleezza Rice and Colin Powell both benefitted from affirmative action (and support it) BUT Ben Carson didn't

⇒ Some republicans support affirmative action for electoral reasons - such republicans want to be seen as compassionate conservatism (as this shows a softer, more electable side)

dec